Project NSX: Part 9 – Designing, Fitting and Testing a 3D Printed Door Card Frame

Acura NSX Center Door Frame Rear 3D print vs OEM

The interface where the center door frame locks into the front door frame is matched identically.

Acura NSX Door Frame Rear Fitment

The 3d Printed piece fits perfectly.

Acura NSX Door Frame Test Pieces

After verifying that the design fits, extensive testing was done on multiple different materials.  PLA is the most common thermoplastic used in 3D printing, but it warps from UV rays and softens in temps that can be found inside a car on a summer day.  Carbon-fiber reinforced PLA and a few other materials held up to the heat and UV rays.

Acura NSX 3D printed door frame destructive test pieces

Countless destructive tests were performed on entire spools (the plastic printing filament is wound on 0.8-1KG spools) of different materials, brands, and print settings.  Their performance was benchmarked against the strength of the OEM ABS plastic.  Yes, OEM pieces were destroyed to ensure the new printed parts were actually stronger.

When 3D printing parts, there are tons of different settings from build plate temperature, extruder temperature, print speed, feed rate, cooling, layer height, retraction distance and rate, etc… that all effect the finish product’s texture, dimensional accuracy, strength, and stiffness.  This photo is less than 1/10th of the spools and spools worth of destroyed parts that filled up a rather large trash can in order to have the confidence that the 3D printed part is stronger than OEM.

Acura NSX door frame test pieces vs OEM

Different materials have different shades of ‘black’ and different textures.  Carbon Fiber-reinforced materials tend to be more of a metallic grey than a true ‘black’.

Table of Contents:

Page 1 – Problem: Broken Door Frame Tabs
Page 2 – Broken Tabs Con’t & New OEM Front & Rear
Page 3 – Replacing Front & Rear Frames, Laser Scanning
Page 4 – Drawing & Designing Door Frames
Page 5 – 3D Printing Door Frames
Page 6 – Test Fitting & Destructive Testing
Page 7 – Redesigning NSX Door Frame & Finished Product

5 comments

  1. Have you looked into black PEI like ULTEM9085? It’s pretty amazing for a FDM material. We have a lot of parts made with it, but we aren’t printing it ourselves so I don’t know if it’s something limited to the very expensive commercial/industrial printers.

  2. You guys should try a Nylon CF like Esun EPA CF. the layer lines basically dissappear and you wont need to worry about car temps. I can promise those will deform on a hot day when you pull on the door card.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*